Our best offer of the year is here! Up to $1,150 off!* Sign up by 11/20


Facet vs. managing your money yourself: Which is right for you?

The short answer:

Managing your own money saves advisory fees and gives you total control, which could make sense in certain situations. On the other hand, partnering with a flat-fee financial planner can help bridge the gap when you want the reassurance that you’re doing the right things with your money. They can help you navigate behavioral blind spots, multi-year tax strategies, estate planning and more for a predictable flat cost. The right choice depends on your portfolio complexity, available time, and how much you value an ongoing accountability partner and expert.

Wife and husband review financial documents seated at table with laptop

Jump to a section:

Key takeaways:

  • DIY money management and investing keeps direct advisory fees at zero, which can be great for those early in their journey with simple financial footprints.
  • Professional behavioral coaching and expert financial advice can significantly help bridge the cost gap by preventing emotional selling and optimizing asset location.
  • Traditional AUM advisors charge a percentage of your portfolio, whereas modern flat-fee planning decouples advice from your investments.
  • The right path hinges on your personal capacity , financial complexity, and desire for an objective sounding board.

How you choose to direct your money is deeply personal, and it reflects what you value most in life. Whether you love optimizing spreadsheets on weekends or feel drained by financial chores, choosing how to manage your wealth is about matching your finances with your life goals. It is completely normal to wonder if you are leaving money on the table or spending valuable hours on tasks someone else could streamline for you.

What is managing your money yourself (doing it yourself or DIY) and what is partnering with a flat-fee planner?

Managing your personal finances comes down to two primary approaches: handling every single detail on your own, or teaming up with a specialized partner.

Defining the DIY approach

The DIY route is built on personal effort and self-directed tools.

  • The mechanics: You manage your investments and accounts using discount brokerages like Fidelity, Schwab, or Vanguard (among others). You might lean on robo-advisors, personal spreadsheets, financial podcasts, books, and tax preparation software to guide your choices.
  • The scope: You shoulder every single responsibility yourself. That includes setting asset allocations, rebalancing portfolios, tax-loss harvesting, running retirement projections, setting up estate planning documents, evaluating insurance policies, and navigating complex equity compensation decisions.

Defining a flat-fee financial planning partner like Facet

A modern flat-fee model rethinks how guidance is delivered.

  • The core structure: It decouples the cost of advice from your portfolio size. Instead of charging an Assets Under Management (AUM) fee (typically around 1%) or earning commissions by selling products, it charges a transparent annual flat membership fee.
  • The whole-life scope: It brings investment management together with comprehensive, life-first financial planning. That means working through your investments as needed, as well as other financial topics like debt paydown, multi-year tax strategies, equity compensation (such as RSUs and ISOs), retirement income modeling, and estate planning.
  • The salaried fiduciary team: At Facet, every member works with salaried, CFP® professionals who have zero sales quotas. This allows them to direct their full attention toward objective financial planning and active implementation of the advice to help ensure you get things done.

What are the advantages of doing it yourself?

Handling your own money offers undeniable benefits, especially when your financial life is just getting started.

1. Zero direct advisory fees

By managing your own accounts, you bypass the typical 0.30% to 1.25%+ annual AUM fee drag, as well as flat annual membership fees. Every dollar stays invested in your desired investment vehicles to compound quietly.

2. Complete autonomy and total control

You never have to delegate. You decide exactly where every single dollar lives, how it is invested, and when it moves. There is no coordination friction, and you never have to schedule check-ins with an outside professional.

3. Personal financial literacy and empowerment

Rolling up your sleeves turns abstract finance into real-world skill. DIYers gain a deep, practical understanding of their cash flow, portfolio allocation, and marginal tax brackets.

4. Simplicity for straightforward financial situations

If you are early in your career with a single W-2 income, manageable debt, standard retirement accounts like a 401(k) or Roth IRA, and no complex equity or estate needs, a basic portfolio is easy to run and remarkably low maintenance.

What are the disadvantages of doing it yourself?

While the direct cost is zero, doing everything yourself can introduce hidden costs in taxes, time, and emotional decision-making.

1. The "behavior gap" and emotional decision-making

Staying calm when markets swing is harder than it looks. In its Advisor’s Alpha™ research, Vanguard quantifies the total value of professional advice at roughly 3% net per year. Behavioral coaching alone represents roughly 100 basis points (1%) of that value by preventing panic selling during market drops and curbing performance-chasing during bull runs.

Without an objective sounding board, DIYers often face cognitive biases such as loss aversion, recency bias, and analysis paralysis.

2. The time, complexity, and mental burden

Research highlighted by Michael Kitces and Carl Richards shows that the greatest value of financial planning is often intangible: clarity, peace of mind, and aligning capital with life values.

Staying up to date on shifting tax laws, Roth conversion thresholds, and the latest tax considerations takes dozens of hours each year. That is time you could spend with family, on hobbies, or advancing your career.

3. Missed "tax alpha" and execution blind spots

DIYers often look at accounts in isolation rather than managing a portfolio with holistic tax coordination. Vanguard attributes up to 0.75% to 1.0%+ in annual net value to tax-efficient rebalancing, asset location across account types, and intentional withdrawal sequencing. Missing out on multi-year bracket optimization or capital gains distribution planning can silently erode returns over time.

4. The accountability and implementation deficit

Knowing what to do is not the same as getting it done. Research from eMoney Advisor highlights that unadvised individuals frequently struggle with implementation. In contrast, 61% of clients working with modern advisors report reduced financial anxiety, and 67% feel motivated thanks to ongoing accountability.

Many DIYers know they need an estate plan, updated beneficiary designations, or proper term life insurance, but put it off indefinitely without an accountability partner to see it through.

Comparing DIY, traditional AUM, and modern flat-fee planning

Here is how a modern flat-fee model bridges the gap between DIY savings and full-service fiduciary advice:

Dimension Doing It Yourself (DIY) Traditional Advisor (1% AUM) Modern Flat-Fee Planner (Facet)
Pricing Model $0 in advisory fees (only fund expense ratios) 0.30%–1.25%+ of total assets under management Transparent, annual flat membership fee
Fee Scaling Flat ($0) regardless of account size "Wealth Tax": Fee can increase when your portfolio increases Fixed: Fee does not increase simply because your portfolio grows
Advisor Role & Incentives 100% on you Dual role: Typically planning + client acquisition/sales 100% Planning: Salaried CFP® professionals with zero sales role
Scope of Advice Dependent on personal knowledge Typically portfolio-centric (liquid accounts) Whole-life scope: Taxes, equity comp, estate*, cash flow, retirement and more
Behavioral Guardrails None (solitary decision-making) Available, but often tied to periodic reviews Ongoing CFP® professional sounding board & accountability partner
Time & Effort Required High (continual research, monitoring, execution) Moderate (scheduling meetings, manual paperwork approvals) Low (onboarding concierge + mobile app access + 1-click actions to get it done)
Account Minimums $0 Often $100K to $1M+ for planner access $0 account minimums required

*Facet is not an attorney and does not provide legal advice or directly prepare estate planning documents. Estate planning services are provided through Facet’s designated estate planning partner Wealth.com and are available for an additional fee to all Facet members. Partner terms and conditions may apply.

Which model is right for you?

Your financial life is an evolving journey. Here is a framework to help you choose the right path for your situation.

When doing it yourself can make the most sense

  • Simple financial footprint: You have a single or dual W-2 income, straightforward debt, rent or have a standard mortgage, and hold your assets in standard retirement accounts.
  • Financial hobbyists: You genuinely love reading tax code updates, analyzing index weightings, and rebalancing spreadsheets in your free time.
  • Early accumulation phase: Your total assets are at a stage where paying even a flat annual membership fee would represent a disproportionately large percentage of your net worth.
  • Emotional fortitude: You have lived through major market downturns like 2008 or 2020 without altering your long-term strategy or liquidating to cash.

When a flat-fee financial planner can be the better fit

  • Busy professionals needing execution support: You know the steps you need to take, but you lack the bandwidth to manage paperwork, coordinate estate documents, or rebalance accounts.
  • Desire for an objective fiduciary: You want guidance from a salaried CFP® professional without commissions or sales quotas.
  • Building some investment momentum: You are looking for expert guidance but want to avoid the traditional 1% AUM fee that grows larger simply because your portfolio grows.
  • Rising life complexity: You need help managing equity compensation like RSUs or ISOs, multi-state tax questions, business equity, or estate planning.
  • Pre-retirees and near-retirees: You are shifting from saving wealth to spending it in retirement, which demands careful tax-bracket management, Social Security timing, and income bucketing.

Sources & regulatory references

The Facet difference

At Facet, we believe high-quality financial planning should enrich your life beyond expectation. We have left behind the traditional asset-based fee structure to create a clean, member-first experience.

With our transparent flat-fee membership, you get full access to a salaried CFP® professional who looks at your whole life, from career moves and equity compensation to taxes and retirement roadmaps. Because our planners do not earn commissions or sell products, their advice is focused on your goals. By pairing human expertise with intuitive technology, we make it simple to turn your financial intentions into real, completed actions.

Ready to get more organized and have more clarity with your money? Schedule a free call with Facet. We’ll show you how a personalized financial roadmap, built for you by a CFP® professional, can turn your money into a tool to help you live a better life today, and feel more confident about tomorrow.

Disclosures

The information, opinions, and market data presented herein are prepared by Facet Wealth, Inc. (“Facet”), an SEC-registered investment adviser, for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute individualized investment, financial, tax, or legal advice, nor a recommendation or offer to buy or sell any security.

Market data and economic commentary referenced are obtained from sources believed to be reliable and are confirmed accurate as of the date of publication. Facet assumes no obligation to update or supplement this material to reflect subsequent market shifts or developments.

Investing involves inherent risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Asset allocation and diversification strategies do not ensure a profit or protect against loss in declining markets. SEC registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

©2026 Facet Wealth, Inc. All Rights Reserved

FAQs

It depends, but it typically does, especially as your portfolio grows. Under an AUM model charging 1%, a $1,000,000 portfolio can cost $10,000 every year, and that fee can double if your portfolio doubles to $2,000,000. With a flat fee, your cost remains flat and predictable regardless of how much your investments grow.

At Facet, you can. Many people enjoy selecting individual investments or running their day-to-day accounts, but partner with a CFP® professional for high-impact areas or decisions they don’t want to make alone.

Investors frequently hurt their long-term performance by reacting to short-term market headlines, such as selling during downturns or buying after large market run-ups. A CFP® professional acts as an objective sounding board to keep you aligned with your long-term roadmap, avoiding costly, emotion-driven trades.

About Facet

Facet is a national, SEC-registered investment advisor (RIA) and consumer fintech leader dedicated to making expert financial planning accessible to everyone.

Through a transparent, flat-fee membership model, Facet provides objective guidance designed to put the member’s best interest first—always. Unlike traditional firms that often take a cut of your returns or charge by the hour, Facet’s affordable fee doesn’t change even as your money grows, helping you keep more of your own money for the life you want to live.

Facet combines user-friendly technology with a dedicated team of CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® professionals to deliver a personalized roadmap for every aspect of a member’s financial life. This comprehensive approach covers everything from the big milestones to everyday decisions—including investment management, tax strategy, equity compensation, and retirement planning—evolving as your life and opportunities unfold. Facet’s mission is to empower individuals to move beyond “standard” advice, helping them make confident decisions and live more enriched lives through financial planning the way it should be: simple, guided, and all about you.

Explore more articles

Wife and husband review financial documents seated at table with laptop

Facet vs. managing your money yourself: Which is right for you?

How you choose to direct your money is deeply personal, and it reflects what you value most in life. Whether you love optimizing spreadsheets on weekends or feel drained by financial chores, choosing how to manage your wealth is about matching your finances with your life goals. It is completely normal to wonder if you ... Read more

7 Min Read
Man reading paperwork at home in front of computer

What to do when a stock you own declines significantly

With many AI-related stocks like Nvidia experiencing significant declines in late 2026, you may be wondering how to handle underperforming assets. Nvidia stock has dropped over 30% since October 6, in large part due to the ouster of co-founder Jensen Huang as CEO. But Nvidia is hardly alone. As of November 18, more than half ... Read more

5 Min Read
A person's hand gently cradling a small, pink piggy bank on a wooden table, symbolizing savings and personal finance. In the blurry background, a person is seen wearing a dark jacket over a white shirt, using a calculator. Natural light filters through an indoor setting with green foliage outside a window, creating a warm, hopeful atmosphere for budgeting, investment, or financial planning.

Should you hold cash in your investment portfolio?

Many investors hold cash as part of their portfolio. This could include anything from money at a bank savings account, a money market fund, short-term CDs or T-Bills, etc. There are some situations where a cash position is sensible. It is true that cash-like investments almost never lose money, even over very short periods. However, ... Read more

5 Min Read

Get started

To schedule a free consultation with a Facet expert, fill out the form below and we will contact you within 24 hours.

By submitting this form, you acknowledge that you have directly provided the email and phone number contact information listed, further acknowledge that Facet Wealth has the option to use either method to contact you, and agree to the terms set forth in our Company Privacy Notice. Message frequency varies, and message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt-out of messages, and email [email protected] for help

OR
To speak with someone now, call us at
1-888-826-6401