Our best offer of the year is here! Up to $1,150 off!* Sign up by 11/20


What to do when a stock you own declines significantly

The short answer:

A significant drop in a stock’s price usually indicates that the broader market believes the company’s future prospects have fundamentally changed. Instead of anchoring on former price highs or holding a declining stock to avoid regret, you should objectively assess whether that specific company still aligns with your broader financial plan. Ultimately, focusing on a broadly diversified portfolio could provide a more reliable path to achieving your long-term goals than trying to predict when an individual stock might rebound.

Man reading paperwork at home in front of computer

Jump to a section:

Key takeaways:

  1. Significant price drops usually signal a fundamental shift: A large decline in a stock's price typically indicates that the broader market believes something major has changed about the company’s future business prospects.
  2. Past highs do not predict future performance: Investors should beware of behavioral biases—such as "anchoring" on a former high price or holding a losing stock to avoid regret—when deciding whether to sell.
  3. Declines reflect institutional selling: Because institutional investors drive the vast majority of stock market trading, an individual holding onto a rapidly declining stock is essentially betting they have better information than Wall Street analysts.
  4. Individual stock risk must align with your financial plan: Successfully picking individual stocks is exceedingly difficult; decisions to hold or sell should prioritize your long-term financial goals and the risk-mitigating benefits of a diversified portfolio over tax implications alone.

With many AI-related stocks like Nvidia experiencing significant declines in late 2026, you may be wondering how to handle underperforming assets. Nvidia stock has dropped over 30% since October 6, in large part due to the ouster of co-founder Jensen Huang as CEO. But Nvidia is hardly alone. As of November 18, more than half of the tech stocks in the S&P 500 are down at least 25% from their 2026 highs.

So what should you do with a stock that is far from its highs? Panic selling isn’t the right answer, but neither is sticking your head in the sand, hoping the stock rebounds. You want to consider why the stock fell, what that means for its potential future, as well as whether taking individual stock risk really fits your financial plan. In short: figure out why the stock fell, don’t anchor to its old high, remember who is on the other side of the trade, don’t let taxes drive the decision, and ask whether single-stock risk fits your plan at all.

Understanding the reasons behind large stock price drops

A significant stock price decline typically indicates that investors believe a fundamental change has occurred in a company's business prospects.

Stock price moves might feel somewhat random, but they aren’t. In the case of Nvidia, the market seems to perceive three specific impacts of Huang’s departure:

Nvidia is also at risk for a general slowdown in data center construction. We detailed some of the risks that might be increasing to AI stocks in a recent article, and these are the main reasons why so many AI-related stocks have declined substantially since this summer. The risks include:

Of course, these aren’t the only reasons why a stock might decline significantly. However, if you own an AI-related stock that is down 25% or more from its 2026 highs, it is probably due to some combination of these factors.

What is anchoring bias, and why does it matter when a stock falls?

Anchoring bias in investing generally occurs when an investor fixates on a past price—such as a recent high—rather than evaluating a company's current fundamentals.

Nvidia stock hit a high of $239 on October 6, 2026. It is tempting to think that if the stock once traded that high, it could trade that high again. However, there is always a reason why a stock has declined. In a very real sense, the version of Nvidia that traded at $239 isn’t the same company that exists today.

Anchoring isn’t the only behavioral bias investors sometimes have in relation to falling stocks. Regret avoidance is where an investor hangs on to a stock rather than admit they should have sold earlier (or never bought in the first place). I have seen this plague professional investors as well as individuals doing it on their own. I’ve many times heard someone say something like “it is too cheap to sell now.” To me, that usually means they wish they had sold it before, and are just hanging on to avoid regret.

Remember, you don’t get to rewind history and sell the stock at its former high. Your decision to keep holding the stock today should be entirely about the future, not the past.

Who is selling when a stock drops?

A declining stock price often reflects heavy selling by institutional investors, who account for the vast majority of daily market trading.

About 90% of all stock trading is done by institutional investors. This includes everything from big banks to hedge funds to large money managers. These kinds of institutions employ armies of stock analysts who pore over company financial statements, news items, sales data, etc. They also get special access to company management through conferences and even private meetings. In other words, these analysts spend all day every day thinking about nothing else but how to value the companies they cover.

When a stock is declining, especially a very large company like Nvidia, it is likely that a lot of the selling is coming from these big institutional investors.

If you decide to keep the stock, in a sense you are saying you know something they don’t. In other words, if these sophisticated investors are selling, it is because they think the stock will keep underperforming. That view might turn out to be right or it might be wrong, but do you want to bet your retirement that they are wrong?

Should taxes keep you from selling a stock that’s fallen?

While the tax implications of selling a stock are important, capital gains taxes should generally be a secondary consideration behind making the right strategic investment decision.

Taxes are another factor that can lead to investor indecision. If you have owned Nvidia for multiple years, today’s price may still be above your purchase price. If you own the stock in a taxable account, you will owe tax if you sell.

However, remember that you can’t avoid paying tax at some point if you are going to use this money in your lifetime. It is a matter of whether you pay the tax now or later.

At Facet, we prefer to focus on building the right portfolio first, and then consider how much tax it would cost to get there. Sometimes that means pacing sales over multiple years, or using tools like direct indexing. However, we want our first priority to ultimately get to the right portfolio.

Does owning individual stocks fit your financial plan?

Holding individual stocks carries specific risks that should be carefully evaluated against your broader, long-term financial plan.

Too often when investors are thinking about selling a stock, they focus solely on whether the stock will go up or down. We believe that is missing the point. You want to build an investment portfolio that maximizes the chances you reach your goals. For example, if your goal is to retire by a certain date with a certain income stream, focus on what is most likely to get you there.

We generally don’t think trying to pick stock market winners is the way to achieve this. It is certainly true that picking the right stock can make you a lot of money. Even with this recent large drop in Nvidia stock, it is still up almost 7,000% over the last decade as of November 18, 2026.

However, we believe successfully picking stock market winners is exceedingly difficult. Facet analyzed every company that was in the S&P 500 from 2016 to 2026 (including those that left the index). Only 13% of companies performed better than the whole index. Worse, 33% of stocks lost money outright. This suggests you had more than double the chance of picking a stock that lost money as you did a stock that did better than the whole S&P.

Performance of S&P 500 individual stocks

Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices

With only 13% of S&P 500 stocks beating the index, we think the odds are stacked against anyone picking stock market winners year after year. Hence why we think if you want to maximize the chance you achieve your financial goals, trying to pick individual stock winners is problematic. Your range of outcomes is probably quite wide. We think a diversified portfolio could narrow the range of outcomes, and if that’s true, it could also improve your chances of reaching your financial goals.

A big drop is a signal to reassess, not to panic or to wait for a rebound. Make the decision about the future, and about your plan, not about the old high.

Ready to get more organized and have more clarity with your money? Schedule a free call with Facet. We’ll show you how a personalized financial roadmap, built for you by a CFP® professional, can turn your money into a tool to help you live a better life today, and feel more confident about tomorrow.

Disclosures

The information, opinions, and market data presented herein are prepared by Facet Wealth, Inc. (“Facet”), an SEC-registered investment adviser, for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute individualized investment, financial, tax, or legal advice, nor a recommendation or offer to buy or sell any security.

Market data and economic commentary referenced are obtained from sources believed to be reliable and are confirmed accurate as of the date of publication. Facet assumes no obligation to update or supplement this material to reflect subsequent market shifts or developments.

Investing involves inherent risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Asset allocation and diversification strategies do not ensure a profit or protect against loss in declining markets. SEC registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

©2026 Facet Wealth, Inc. All Rights Reserved

FAQs

Fixating on a past price is a common behavioral bias known as anchoring. A stock’s previous high has no bearing on its future performance. When a stock’s price drops significantly, it usually indicates that the market believes the company’s future prospects have fundamentally changed. Your decision to hold or sell should be based entirely on the company’s current outlook and how it fits your long-term financial plan, rather than what the price used to be.

Many AI stocks have experienced steep declines recently due to a combination of shifting industry fundamentals and increasing risks. These can include uncertainty around company leadership, potential government restrictions on international chip sales, rising borrowing costs to fund new data centers, and potential regulatory shifts regarding AI safety. When these risks increase, institutional investors often sell, which drives prices down.

While taxes are an important consideration, they should generally be secondary to making the right strategic investment decision. If holding an individual stock carries too much risk or no longer aligns with your broader financial goals, it is usually better to prioritize building a properly diversified portfolio. You can then work on a strategy to manage the tax impact over time, rather than letting tax avoidance dictate your investment strategy.

About Facet

Facet is a national, SEC-registered investment advisor (RIA) and consumer fintech leader dedicated to making expert financial planning accessible to everyone.

Through a transparent, flat-fee membership model, Facet provides objective guidance designed to put the member’s best interest first—always. Unlike traditional firms that often take a cut of your returns or charge by the hour, Facet’s affordable fee doesn’t change even as your money grows, helping you keep more of your own money for the life you want to live.

Facet combines user-friendly technology with a dedicated team of CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® professionals to deliver a personalized roadmap for every aspect of a member’s financial life. This comprehensive approach covers everything from the big milestones to everyday decisions—including investment management, tax strategy, equity compensation, and retirement planning—evolving as your life and opportunities unfold. Facet’s mission is to empower individuals to move beyond “standard” advice, helping them make confident decisions and live more enriched lives through financial planning the way it should be: simple, guided, and all about you.

Explore more articles

Man reading paperwork at home in front of computer

What to do when a stock you own declines significantly

With many AI-related stocks like Nvidia experiencing significant declines in late 2026, you may be wondering how to handle underperforming assets. Nvidia stock has dropped over 30% since October 6, in large part due to the ouster of co-founder Jensen Huang as CEO. But Nvidia is hardly alone. As of November 18, more than half ... Read more

5 Min Read
A person's hand gently cradling a small, pink piggy bank on a wooden table, symbolizing savings and personal finance. In the blurry background, a person is seen wearing a dark jacket over a white shirt, using a calculator. Natural light filters through an indoor setting with green foliage outside a window, creating a warm, hopeful atmosphere for budgeting, investment, or financial planning.

Should you hold cash in your investment portfolio?

Many investors hold cash as part of their portfolio. This could include anything from money at a bank savings account, a money market fund, short-term CDs or T-Bills, etc. There are some situations where a cash position is sensible. It is true that cash-like investments almost never lose money, even over very short periods. However, ... Read more

5 Min Read
Woman with a cup of coffee standing in a kitchen and looking at her phone

Are AI stocks in a bubble? Balancing the infrastructure boom with rising risks

Over the last few months, AI-related stocks have been particularly volatile, reviving worries that there could be an AI bubble about to burst. On one hand, the AI buildout is arguably the biggest capital expenditure boom in history. If that continues, it could continue to power strong stock market returns, especially for the companies most ... Read more

6 Min Read

Get started

To schedule a free consultation with a Facet expert, fill out the form below and we will contact you within 24 hours.

By submitting this form, you acknowledge that you have directly provided the email and phone number contact information listed, further acknowledge that Facet Wealth has the option to use either method to contact you, and agree to the terms set forth in our Company Privacy Notice. Message frequency varies, and message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt-out of messages, and email [email protected] for help

OR
To speak with someone now, call us at
1-888-826-6401